Open enrollment: choosing a dental plan for wisdom teeth

A dental plan chosen at open enrollment pays for wisdom tooth surgery next year only if its waiting period for oral surgery ends before your surgery date. Compare which tier holds surgical extraction and anesthesia, the waiting period on that tier, the annual maximum, the deductible, how out-of-network claims are paid and any pre-existing clause, then size your FSA election to match.

What this covers

The question to answer before comparing anything

You can enroll in a dental plan during open enrollment knowing wisdom teeth need to come out, and no plan can refuse you for it, but many plans will not pay for the surgery until a waiting period has passed. The real question is not whether a plan covers oral surgery. It is whether that plan will pay on the specific date you expect to have the surgery, at the specific surgeon you expect to use.

Open enrollment is the one window most people get each year to change coverage without a qualifying life event. Employer plans run their own windows, usually in the autumn. The federal marketplace publishes its dates on healthcare.gov, and federal employees and retirees choosing dental coverage under the Federal Employees Dental and Vision Insurance Program find the open season dates on opm.gov. Coverage chosen in these windows usually starts on January 1. That start date is the anchor for every calculation in this article.

If you already know that you, or a teenager on your plan, will need third molars removed in the coming year, you are in an unusual position. Most people pick a dental plan on premium and on whether their usual dentist is in the network. You have a known, scheduled, relatively large claim coming, and the plan features that decide whether it pays are the ones buried in the limitations section, not the ones on the comparison grid.

Dr. Peter K. Cudjoe seated in a consultation room, speaking with a patient whose back is to the camera

Waiting periods: the clause that can cancel a whole year

A new dental plan often will not cover wisdom teeth removal right away, because many individually purchased plans attach a waiting period to the category that holds surgical extraction, and claims for that category are denied until the period ends. Employer group plans frequently waive waiting periods, so the answer depends on where the plan comes from as well as on its wording.

Do the arithmetic before you enroll. Suppose a plan starts on January 1 and puts surgical extraction in a major services tier with a twelve month waiting period. That category opens on January 1 of the following year. Any surgery performed during the coming year, in February, in June or in the week before Christmas, falls inside the waiting period and is unpaid. You would pay premiums for twelve months and receive nothing toward the procedure you bought the plan for.

That is not a hidden trick. It is the purpose of the clause. A waiting period exists so that people cannot buy coverage for a known procedure, use it, and cancel. If you are buying a plan specifically because surgery is coming, you are exactly the case the clause was written for, and you should assume it applies unless the plan documents say otherwise.

Three situations change the picture. A plan with a six month wait on the relevant tier opens in July, which may suit a teenager planning surgery during the summer break. A plan with no waiting period on that tier, which is common through employers, pays from the start date. And some plans waive the wait for anyone who can show continuous prior dental coverage without a gap, typically by sending a letter from the previous plan. If you are moving from one plan to another rather than starting from nothing, ask about that waiver before you choose, and keep the letter.

The honest conclusion for some readers is uncomfortable. If every plan open to you carries a twelve month wait on oral surgery and the surgery cannot reasonably wait until the following January, a new dental plan may contribute nothing to it. In that case the premium is buying cleanings and exams, which may still be worth it, but it is not buying the surgery. Knowing that in November lets you plan the fee through an FSA, savings or financing rather than discovering it from a denial letter in the spring.

Basic or major: where the plan files the surgery and the anesthesia

Wisdom tooth removal is classed as basic on some dental plans and major on others, and many plans split it, placing a simple extraction of an erupted tooth under basic services and surgical removal of an impacted tooth under major services or a separate oral surgery category. The classification matters because it sets both the percentage the plan pays and the waiting period that applies.

Most dental plans sort care into three tiers. Preventive care, such as exams and cleanings, is usually paid at the highest percentage with no waiting period. Basic services, such as fillings and simple extractions, are paid at a middle percentage and sometimes carry a short wait. Major services are paid at the lowest percentage and carry the longest waits. A plan that pays a generous share for basic services tells you very little until you know whether your surgery is basic on that plan.

Anesthesia deserves its own line in your comparison. Plans often treat general anesthesia and IV sedation for dental surgery separately from the extraction, sometimes covering them only for certain procedures or when specific clinical conditions are documented, sometimes placing them in a different tier, and sometimes excluding them. A plan can open the extraction category on a given date and still decline the anesthesia on the same claim. When you read the summary of benefits, search for the words anesthesia, sedation and general anesthesia, not only extraction.

Medical plans are a separate question. A medical plan occasionally pays for removal of an impacted tooth when there is documented disease, such as a cyst, a tumour or a spreading infection, but routine removal of symptom free or crowded third molars is generally treated as dental. That is the situation for most teenagers and young adults having wisdom teeth out, so a medical plan should not be chosen on the hope that it will carry this surgery.

Plan features to compare when third molar surgery is planned for next year
FeatureWhere to find itWhy it matters for wisdom tooth surgery
Tier for surgical extractionSummary of benefits, oral surgery or extraction linesSets the percentage paid and which waiting period applies
Waiting period on that tierLimitations section of the certificate of coverageDecides whether a claim next year pays anything at all
Anesthesia and sedation rulesAnesthesia or general anesthesia entries and exclusionsOften covered on narrower terms than the extraction itself
Annual maximumSummary of benefits, near the deductibleCaps what the plan pays in a year; surgery can use most of it
Deductible and how often it resetsSummary of benefits; calendar year or plan yearA January surgery on a new plan year meets it again
Out-of-network paymentOut-of-network section; allowed amount wordingDecides whether a surgeon outside the network is paid at all
Pre-existing condition wordingExclusions and limitationsCan reach a tooth already noted on an earlier X-ray
Dependent age limitEligibility sectionDecides whether a 19 or 20 year old is still on the family plan
Dr. Peter K. Cudjoe checking anaesthesia monitoring equipment in a treatment room

Annual maximums and deductibles

The annual maximum is the most a dental plan will pay toward your care in one benefit year, and wisdom tooth surgery with anesthesia can use a large share of it, or all of it, in a single visit. Once the maximum is reached the plan pays nothing more until it resets, so a low maximum limits what any percentage on the benefits grid can deliver.

Read the maximum together with the percentage. A plan that pays a high share of oral surgery but has a modest annual maximum will stop paying at the cap, and the percentage stops mattering past that point. When you compare plans, look for the maximum per person, whether anesthesia counts against it, and whether other care you expect next year, such as fillings or a crown for a parent on the same plan, will draw from the same person's maximum before the surgery happens.

The deductible is the amount you pay before the plan starts sharing costs, usually waived for preventive care and applied to basic and major services. Check whether it is per person or per family, and whether it resets on January 1 or on a plan year anniversary that falls some other month. The reset date matters because it decides which year a surgery is counted in, and that leads straight into the timing problem below.

Some families with several third molars to remove ask whether the surgery can be split across two benefit years to use two maximums. Occasionally that is reasonable. More often it means two anesthetics, two recoveries and a second surgery that slips. That trade-off belongs in a conversation with the surgeon who has seen the X-rays, and our article on annual maximums and splitting surgery across years sets out how to weigh it.

Networks and what an out-of-network claim pays

A dental HMO, often called a DHMO, generally pays nothing for an out-of-network oral surgeon except in narrow cases such as an approved referral or an emergency, because the plan works through assigned in-network providers. A dental PPO usually pays something out of network, but often at a lower level, calculated on the plan's own allowed amount rather than on the surgeon's fee.

If you already know which surgeon or practice you intend to use, check whether that practice is in the network of each plan you are considering, and if it is not, ask the plan exactly how it pays an out-of-network oral surgery claim. The useful questions are concrete. Is there out-of-network coverage at all? Is it paid at the same percentage as in network, or a lower one? What allowed amount does the plan use? Is the payment sent to you or to the surgeon? A plan with a strong in-network grid and no out-of-network benefit is worth nothing at a surgeon outside its network.

The reverse also applies. If an HMO plan suits your budget and your family, it can still work for wisdom teeth, provided you are comfortable having the surgery with an oral surgeon the plan assigns or approves. That is a legitimate choice, and for many families it is the sensible one. The mistake is choosing a network plan and then expecting it to pay for a surgeon outside the network. Our article on whether a dental HMO or PPO suits oral surgery goes through the trade-off in more detail.

Teenagers heading to college add a geographic wrinkle. If surgery is likely to happen near a campus in another state, a network built around your home county may not reach it. Check whether the plan's network, or its out-of-network benefit, follows the student.

Dr. Peter K. Cudjoe passing a printed treatment plan across a desk to a patient

Missing-tooth and pre-existing condition clauses

A dental plan can sometimes limit coverage for a condition that existed before enrollment, depending on its wording and on state law, so a wisdom tooth already noted as impacted on last year's X-ray may be affected by a pre-existing condition clause on some individual plans. Most plans do not use such clauses for extractions, but the only way to know is to read the exclusions.

Do not assume that the protections you know from medical insurance carry over automatically. The Affordable Care Act bars medical plans from excluding pre-existing conditions. Stand-alone dental plans are generally treated as a separate category of coverage, called excepted benefits, and several of the rules that apply to medical plans do not apply to them in the same way. Pediatric dental coverage for children under 19 is an essential health benefit on the marketplace, and healthcare.gov explains how it is offered in your state. For adults, the plan contract governs.

The missing-tooth clause is a different and usually less relevant clause. It excludes replacing a tooth that was already missing when coverage began, for example with a bridge or denture. A wisdom tooth that is still present is not a missing tooth, so the clause rarely affects its removal. People confuse the two because they often sit in the same paragraph of the certificate.

One rule does not bend for any clause. Never manage a coverage question by leaving history out of the medical form you give the surgeon. The surgeon needs a complete history to plan anesthesia safely, and the earlier records exist whether you mention them or not. A claim dispute is a paperwork problem. An incomplete anesthesia history is a safety problem.

Late December or January: the timing trap

Whether wisdom teeth should come out in December or January for insurance depends on which plan covers you on each date. A December surgery is billed to this year's plan, its remaining annual maximum and a deductible you may already have met. A January surgery is billed to next year's plan, which resets the deductible and maximum and, if it is a new plan, may still be inside a waiting period.

Claims are judged on the date of service, the day the surgery is performed, not the day you booked it or the day the bill arrives. That single rule creates the trap. A family that switches plans on January 1 can find that the old plan, which had long since passed its waiting period, would have paid for a December surgery, while the new plan pays nothing for a January one because its waiting period has just started.

How the same surgery is treated on either side of January 1
SituationSurgery in late DecemberSurgery in January
Keeping the same plan into next yearUses what is left of this year's maximum; deductible may already be metFresh maximum and fresh deductible on the same terms
Switching to a new plan on January 1Paid by the old plan if coverage was active and its waiting period has passedPaid by the new plan only if its waiting period for that tier is zero or waived
Losing dental coverage on December 31Last date this plan can pay; surgery after it is not covered by this planNo dental plan; the fee falls to you, an FSA or savings
Turning 19 or ageing off a parent's dental planMay still be covered as a dependent, depending on the plan's age ruleMay need the young adult's own plan, with its own waiting period

December has practical limits too. The last two weeks of the year are when many families try to use remaining benefits, and surgical schedules fill early. Recovery usually means a few days of rest at home, and planning that over the holidays has its own appeal and its own problems, with travel, gatherings and closed pharmacies. If you intend to use December, start the conversation with the surgeon's office well before it, so that consultation, X-rays and any pre-treatment estimate are done in time.

January suits a different family. If you are keeping the same plan, the deductible has already been met this year and the maximum is mostly unused, December may be the efficient date. If this year's maximum is already spent on other care, a January date on the same plan starts from a full maximum. And if you are switching plans, the decision about December belongs before you sign the new enrollment form, not after.

FSA and HSA elections made in the same window

Putting money in a health FSA for wisdom teeth removal can make sense if the surgery is planned for the coming plan year, because dental surgery is generally an eligible medical expense and the full annual election is usually available from the first day of the plan year. The risk is that unused FSA money may be forfeited, so the election should match a realistic plan rather than a hope.

The FSA decision is made during the same open enrollment as the dental plan, and the two should be decided together. If your dental plan comparison shows that a new plan's waiting period will leave the surgery unpaid next year, the FSA is often the main tool you have, and sizing the election around a written estimate from the surgeon's office is more reliable than guessing. IRS Publication 502 describes which dental expenses count as medical expenses, and your employer's plan documents describe the grace period or carryover option, if the plan offers one. A plan may offer one of those features or neither, but not both.

A health savings account works differently. You can contribute to an HSA only if you are enrolled in a qualifying high deductible health plan, and the money rolls over from year to year rather than being forfeited, so the timing pressure is weaker. If you are choosing between a high deductible medical plan with an HSA and another medical plan, the coming surgery is one input among many. IRS Publication 969 sets out the eligibility rules, and our article on using an HSA or FSA for oral surgery covers how people use these accounts for third molars.

Two details catch families. An FSA can usually pay for a dependent's care, such as a teenager's surgery, if that child is your tax dependent, even when the child has dental coverage elsewhere. And the FSA pays for the date of service in that plan year, so a surgery that slips from December into January may need next year's election, not this year's.

Dr. Peter K. Cudjoe walking along a clinic corridor in scrubs

A November checklist for each plan you are considering

Comparison sites show premiums and headline percentages. The details that decide your surgery claim come from the plan documents and a phone call. The neutral places to start are your employer's benefits portal, healthcare.gov for marketplace plans, opm.gov for federal employees and retirees, and the consumer pages published by the National Association of Dental Plans, which explain plan types and terms without selling a particular policy. If a plan's answer conflicts with its documents, the Florida Department of Financial Services runs a consumer helpline for insurance questions.

  1. Which tier holds surgical removal of an impacted wisdom tooth, and which holds simple extraction of an erupted one?
  2. What is the waiting period on each of those tiers, and on general anesthesia or IV sedation?
  3. Can the waiting period be waived for prior continuous coverage, and what proof does the plan need?
  4. What is the annual maximum per person, and does anesthesia count against it?
  5. Is the deductible per person or per family, and does it reset on January 1 or on another date?
  6. Is the surgeon you intend to use in network, and if not, how does the plan pay out of network?
  7. Is there any pre-existing condition, prior condition or look-back wording in the exclusions?
  8. Until what age is a dependent covered on this dental plan?
  9. Will the plan accept a pre-treatment estimate before surgery, and how long does it usually take to answer?

Write down the name of the person you spoke with, the date and the call reference number. If the plan later processes the claim differently, that record is what an appeal is built on.

Dr. Peter K. Cudjoe seated beside a patient, both looking at a tablet he is holding

When the tooth should not wait for a plan year

You should not wait until next year's dental plan to have an infected or repeatedly painful wisdom tooth assessed. Infection around a lower wisdom tooth can spread into the spaces of the jaw and neck, and the start date of a dental plan has no influence on how fast that happens. Planning around a benefit year is reasonable only for a quiet tooth with a non-urgent reason for removal.

For many readers the tooth is quiet. A fully impacted third molar seen on a routine X-ray, with no decay on the neighbouring molar, no gum pocket and no history of swelling, is not usually made meaningfully worse by a few months. Scheduling that surgery around a benefit date is a legitimate decision. A partly erupted tooth with repeated episodes of soreness, bad taste or swelling behind the last molar is different, and antibiotics used to stretch the time to a plan date treat the symptom without removing the cause.

Published by The Wisdom Tooth Clinic Miami. General information, not a substitute for an examination and diagnosis by Peter K. Cudjoe, D.D.S..

Further reading

These organizations publish patient information on this subject. They are not affiliated with this practice and have not reviewed this page.